D. Ross, . Norms, . London, H. L. Paul, J. Hart et al., Kelsen Théorie générale des normes « Kelsen's Doctrine of the Unity of Law, International Library of Philosophy and Scientific Method Le contenu et la structure des normes concédant les compétences », op. cit. Commands and Authoritative Legal Reasons Authority The Concept of a Legal System. An Introduction to the Theory of Legal System, pp.348-349, 1968.

E. Pattaro, « Contributo al seminario 'Se la logica si applichi alle norme, p.512, 1986.

. Bentham, Principles of the civil code., Id., Selected Writings on Utilitarianism
DOI : 10.1037/12200-002

D. Bozonis, P. Georgas, . R. Trappe, and . Supplementa, A Theory and Systems of Legal Philosophy, I.V.R. 12 th World Congress, MacCormick, « Legal Obligation and the Imperative Fallacy Oxford Essays in Jurisprudence (Second Series), pp.204-213, 1973.

«. L. Grzegorczyk, impact de la théorie des actes de langage dans le monde juridique : essai de bilan, Théorie des actes de langage, éthique et droit, pp.192-193, 1986.

«. Ross and . The, Rise and Fall of the Doctrine of Performatives, Contemporary Philosophy in Scandinavia, pp.197-212, 1972.

L. M. Eckhoff, J. Friedman, and . Uusitalo, « Norme che sono condizioni sufficiente del loro oggetto?, Vernunft und Erfahrung im Rechtsdenken der Gegenwart Constitutive Rules and the Is-Ought Dichotomy Normative Structures of the Social World, Pozna? Studies in the Philosophy of Science and the Humanities, pp.261-269, 1986.

«. Enciclopedia-iberoamericana-de-filosofía, Teoría general del derecho y de la ciencia jurídica, op. cit., pp. 162, 165; Id., Introducción a la teoría de la norma jurídica, p.316, 1996.

H. Marín, Teoría general del derecho y de la ciencia jurídica, op. cit., p. 164. See also Id, Autoridad- Competencia, p.310

. Id, Introducción a la teoría de la norma jurídica, op. cit, p.314

. Hernández-marín-id, Teoría general del derecho y de la ciencia jurídica, op. cit., p. 163; Id, Autoridad-Competencia, p.37

O. Bentham and . Laws-in-general-id, This insight is also present in E. Zitelmann The concept of « metanorm » is now quite common in the apparatus of legal theory, Geltungsbereich und Anwendungsbereich der Gesetze. Zur Grundlegung der völkerrechtlichen Theorie des Zwischenprivatsrechts Festgabe der Bonner Juristischen Fakultät für Karl Bergbohm zum 70. Geburtstag Nuova civilta delle machine Logica deontica e linguaggio giuridico, pp.93-94, 1919.

«. Pubblicazioni-della-università-di-pavia, ». Studi-nelle-scienze-giuridiche-e-sociali, P. R. Nuova-serie, T. J. Visser, P. Favoreu et al., Pfersmann, « Arguments ontologiques et argumentation juridique Raisonnement juridique et interprétation, De Republica ? 3, Travaux de l'Ecole doctorale de droit public et de droit fiscal, Université de Paris I (Panthéon ? Sorbonne) Bench- Capon, « A Comparison of Four Ontologies for the Design of Legal Knowledge Systems, Précis. Droit public Science politique, pp.16-17, 1989.

O. Bentham and . Laws-in-general, See also Id., An Introduction to the Principles of Morals and Legislation, op. cit, pp.170-171

. Bentham, An Introduction to the Principles of Morals and Legislation, op. cit., p. 227; Id., Of Laws in General, J. Bentham, Of Laws in General, pp.26-28, 0200.

V. O. Quine, From a Logical Point of View. 9 Logico-Philosophical Essays, p.10, 1964.

.. W. 203-ibid and . Quine, Now how are we to adjudicate among rival ontologies? [?] Our acceptance of an ontology is, I think, similar in principle to our acceptance of a scientific theory, say a system of physics: we adopt, at least insofar as we are reasonable, the simplest conceptual scheme into which the disordered fragments of raw experience can be fitted and arranged, Fr. trans. M. Clavelin, pp.17-32, 1993.

«. Gochet and . L-'empirisme-relatif-de-quine, La philosophie anglo-saxonne, coll. « Premier cycle 344; W.V.O. Quine, La poursuite de la vérité, pp.137-139, 1994.

H. James, A General View of a Complete Code of Laws, op. cit., p. 208. 222 J. Bentham, Of Laws in General 223 Only Ross also seems to be aware of the defects of this position, which he embraces, see A, Bentham on the Individuation of Laws Directives and Norms, op. cit, pp.115-116, 1953.

P. P. Hernández-marín-barcelona, Introducción a la teoría de la norma jurídica, op. cit., pp. 309-310; Id., « Autoridad-Competencia », op. cit., p. 123, Normativity and Norms. Critical Perspectives on Kelsenian Themes Sobre la existencia de las normas jurídicas, op. cit, pp.37-38, 1975.

O. Ross, . Law, O. Justice, . C. Cit, E. Alchourrón et al., Validity and the Conflict between Legal Positivism and Natural Law Análisis lógico y Derecho, op. cit., p. 450; R.A. Caracciolo, « Sistema jurídico y regla de reconocimiento The Concept of Law, Revista jurídica de Buenos Aires Doxa 305; R. Guastini, « Normas supremas Hernández Marín, Introducción a la teoría de la norma jurídica, op. cit, pp.141-142, 0310.

«. Moritz and . Sätze, Erlaubnissätze und deontische Logik

R. Aspelin, C. W. Lund, and . Gleerup, Philosophical Essays Dedicated to Gunnar, pp.108-121, 1963.

«. Kalinowski, . M. Logique-et-philosophie-du-droit-subjectif, . Chisholm, . Dodrecht, and D. Boston, Analysis and Metaphhysics. Essays in Honor of R, Some Definitions for the Theory of Rules, pp.278-337, 1973.

C. E. Alchourrón and E. Bulygin, Análisis lógico y Derecho 146-149; N. Bobbio, Teoria della norma giuridica, Mazarese, « Permesso forte e permesso debole: note a margine Analisi e diritto Théorie pure du droit, pp.235-243, 1958.

«. Williams and . The, 1130-1131; A. Squella, « ¿Cumplen funciones meramente permisivas las normas de competencia?, Anuario de filosofia jurídica y social Février, « Remarques sur la notion de norme permissive, pp.235-237, 1956.

. Bentham, Of Laws in General, op. cit., p. 99; L. François, Le problème de la définition du droit, op. cit, pp.130-131

«. Scarpelli, R. A. Modi-deontici-e-la-completezza-degli-ordinamenti-normativi, D. Guibourg, . Mendonca, and . Permesso, Mazzarese, « Permesso forte e permesso debole: note a margine, pp.244-125

«. Derecho, A. Ross, Directives and Norms, op. cit, J. Raz, Practical Reason and Norms, pp.66-123, 1999.

C. E. Id, E. Alchourrón, M. Bulygin, J. R. Atienza, and . Manero, Sobre la existencia de las normas jurídicas 244-246; J. Ferrer Beltrán, Las normas de competencia, op. cit, Sobre permisos en el derecho The Correlativity of Rights and Duties Weinberger, « Logica delle norme e dominî logici Logica deontica e semantica Temi e disussioni, pp.65-93, 1970.

. Bentham, Of Laws in General, op. cit., p. 99; L. François, Le problème de la définition du droit

J. Atienza, «. Ruiz-manero, and . Sobre, 836, 837; Id., A Theory of Legal Sentences, op. cit., pp. 105, 109, 110; O. Weinberger « The Expressive Conception of Norms: An Impasse for the Logic of Norms, p.833

W. N. Hohfeld, Fundamental Legal Conceptions as Applied in Judicial Reasoning

T. Westport and . Spaak, A Criticism of the Dualism in Law 185-188; Id., Directives and Norms, op. cit., p. 131; D. Makinson, « On the Formal Representation of Rights Relations The Concept of Legal Competence, Christie, Law, Norms and Authority, op. cit., p. 161; J.-L. Gardies « The Fundamental Features of Legal Rationality », op. cit., p. 247; R. Caracciolo, « Due tipi di potere normativo, pp.58-408, 1934.

P. M. Hacker and . Hart, s Philosophy of Law », op. cit., p. 19 n. 21; M.D. Bayles, Hart's Legal Philosophy

C. Wellman and H. L. Hart, A. Squella, « ¿Cumplen funciones meramente permisivas las normas de competencia? », op. cit, Theory of Rights. Persons under Laws Legal Rights Id., Essays on Bentham, pp.44-221, 1873.
URL : https://hal.archives-ouvertes.fr/inserm-00720878

. Bentham, Of Laws in General

S. Nino, . Introduction, H. Aldershot, and . Kong, Rights by a certain authority is forbidden to this authority by virtue of some higher-order norm »; ibid., pp. 200, 201; Id., An Essay in Deontic Logic and the General Theory of Action, The International Library of Essays in Law and Legal Theory xvi. See also Sir J. Salmond, Jurisprudence Acta Philosophica Fennica », Fasc. 21 Ratio, pp.245-94, 1947.

C. E. Alchourrón and E. Bulygin, Normative Systems, op. cit., p. 73; Id., Sobre la existencia de las normas jurídicas

. Bentham, Of Laws in General, op. cit., p. 22. See also ibid, p.19

L. A. Hart, Essays on Bentham, op. cit., p. 241. 241 I assume, however, that due to some of Of Laws in General's developments, an embryonic theory of the validity of law is present The idea of validity also recurs in Bentham, so that Hart's criticisms might be called in to question. I cannot focus on this point here, Bentham on Legal Powers, pp.131-133

E. Alchourrón and E. Bulygin, Análisis lógico y Derecho, op. cit., pp. 462, 490; T. Spaak, The Concept of Legal Competence, op. cit., p. 84; J. Ferrer Beltrán, Las normas de competencia, p. 67; R. von Jhering, pp.319-320

G. Carcaterra, Il normativismo e la forza costitutiva delle norme, p.88, 1988.

». Government, Tapper, « Powers and Secondary Rules of Change, Oxford Essays in Jurisprudence (Second Series) El encaje de las piezas del derecho (segunda parte) Voluntary Obligations and Normative Powers, pp.241-244, 1973.

«. Raz, . Voluntary, N. Obligations, C. E. Powers, E. Alchourrón et al., Análisis lógico y Derecho, op. cit., p. 489; A. Sériaux, Droit canonique, Droit canonique, 2 e éd Précis droit privé, pp.451-470, 1996.

. Ferrer-beltrán, . R. Las-normas-de-competencia,-op.-cit, D. Guibourg, . Mendonca, L. M. Permesso et al., 92-93 n. 161 Análisis lógico y Derecho, op. cit., p. 489, Sobre permisos en el derecho, pp.151-152

O. Ross, . Law, O. Justice, . R. Cit, D. Guibourg et al., 250 See, as regards Scandinavian realism, A See also the French school of legal realism: M. Troper Pour une théorie juridique de l'Etat, op. cit.; Id., La théorie du droit, le droit, Champeil-Desplats, Les principes fondamentaux reconnus par les lois de la République. Principes constitutionnels et justification dans les discours juridiques, préf. M. Troper Agostini, Les normes non valides. Contribution à une théorie générale de l'annulation juridictionnelle des normes, pp.167-131, 1957.

S. J. Austin, Lectures on Jurisprudence or the Philosophy of Positive Laws, pp.354-355

G. See, Tusseau Les normes d'habilitation, op. cit

G. Tripoli and P. Schofield, The Althone Press A Comment on the Commentaries and A Fragment on Government, First Principles Preparatory to Constitutional Code Securities Against Misrule and Other Constitutional Writings for Constitutional Code for the Use of all Nations and all Governments Professing Liberal Opinions, 1970.

J. H. Rosen, . J. Burns, . Cléro, and L. G. Paris, Official Aptitude Maximized; Expense Minimized: as Shewn in the Several Papers Comprised in this Fragment sur le gouvernement et Manuel de sophismes politiques, Fr. trans., pref, Garanties contre l'abus de pouvoir et autres écrits sur la liberté politique, Fr. trans. M.-L. Leroy, Paris, Editions rue d'Ulm / Presses de l'Ecole normale supérieure, coll. « Versions françaises Selected Writings on Utilitarianism Ware, Wordsworth Classics of World Literature Rights, Representation, and Reform: Nonsense upon Stilts and Other Writings on the French Revolution, 1991.

A. Regla and J. Sobre, Definiciones y normas' », in Doxa, pp.273-282, 1990.

A. Cabrera and C. , « Sobre el concepto y tipología de las reglas constitutivas, Anuario de Filosofia del derecho, pp.273-295, 1991.

C. E. Alchourrón and E. Bulygin, Normative Systems Sobre la existencia de las normas jurídicas, Library of Exact Philosophy latinoamericana de investigaciones jurídicas y sociales Análisis lógico y Derecho, 1971.

M. Atienza and J. Ruiz-manero, « Sobre permisos en el derecho, Doxa, pp.15-16, 1994.

J. Austin, Lectures on Jurisprudence or the Philosophy of Positive Laws 12 th impression The Province of Jurisprudence Determined, W.L. Morison (Intro.), 1913.

P. Bailhache, Essai de logique déontique, 1991.

M. D. Bayles, Hart's Legal Philosophy. An Examination, coll. « Law and Philosophy Library », vol.17, 1992.

N. Bobbio, Teoria della norma giuridica, La norme, 1958.

R. A. Caracciolo, Sistema jur??dico y regla de reconocimiento, Doxa, pp.295-309, 1991.
DOI : 10.14198/DOXA1991.9.15

G. Carcaterra, Il normativismo e la forza costitutiva delle norme, 1988.

M. A. Cattaneo, Il positivismo giuridico inglese. Hobbes, Bentham, 1962.

V. Champeil-desplats, Les principes fondamentaux reconnus par les lois de la République Principes constitutionnels et justification dans les discours juridiques, préf. M. Troper, 2001.

D. Sousa-e-brito and J. , « Hart's Criticism of Bentham, pp.449-461, 1979.

G. Fassò and L. G. , Histoire de la philosophie du droit. XIX e et XX e siècles, Fr. trans. C. Rouffet, vol.20, 1976.

J. R. Ferrer-beltrán, . Guastini, and . Madrid, Las normas de competencia Un aspecto de la dinámica jurídica, pról, Centro de estudios políticos y constitutionales ? Boletín oficial del Estado, col. « El Derecho y la Justicia, 2000.

J. Février, « Remarques sur la notion de norme permissive, pp.271-274, 1998.

L. François, Le problème de la définition du droit Introduction à un cours d'évolution de la philosophie du droit à l'époque contemporaine, 1978.

Å. Frändberg, Om analog användning av rättsnormer. En analys av analogibegreppet inom ramen för an allmän juridisk metodologi, 1973.

G. Máynez, E. Lógica-del-juicio-jurídico, B. México, and . Aires, Fondo de cultura económica, col, Publicaciones de Dianoia. Anuario de filosofia Lógica del concepto jurídico, 1955.

J. Gardies, Essai sur les fondements a priori de la rationalité morale et juridique, préf

P. Gochet, ». «-l-'empirisme-relatif-de-quine, and I. M. Meyer, La philosophie anglo-saxonne, .U.F., coll. « Premier cycle, pp.318-347, 1994.

C. Grzegorczyk and T. Studnicki, « Les rapports entre la norme et la disposition légale, pp.243-256, 1974.

C. Grzegorczyk, impact de la théorie des actes de langage dans le monde juridique : essai de bilan », in P. Amselek (dir.), Théorie des actes de langage, éthique et droit, Le droit comme interprétation officielle de la réalité Droits. Revue française de théorie juridique, pp.165-194, 1986.

R. Guibourg, El fenómeno normativo. Acción, norma y sistema. La revolución informática. Niveles del análisis jurídico, Buenos Aires, Editorial Astrea, col. « Filosofía y derecho, Formalization of Competence, 1987.

. Zimmerling, Normative Systems in Legal and Moral Theory, Festschrift for Carlos E. Alchourrón and Eugenio Bulygin, pp.455-473, 1997.

A. Halpin, The concept of a legal power, Oxford Journal of Legal Studies, vol.16, issue.1, pp.129-152, 1996.
DOI : 10.1093/ojls/16.1.129

J. W. Harris, Law and Legal Science. An Inquiry into the Concepts Legal Rule and Legal System, 1979.

H. L. Hart, The Concept of Law Bentham's Of Laws in General, Legal Rights Id., Essays on Bentham. Studies in Jurisprudence and Political Theory, pp.105-126, 1961.

H. Marín and R. , El derecho como dogma, Ciencias jurídicas Historia de la filosofía del Derecho contemporanea, 1984.

W. N. Hohfeld, Fundamental Legal Conceptions as Applied in Judicial Reasoning, 1978.

S. G. Jensen, « On Norms of Conduct and Norms of Competence

P. Georgas, . R. Trappe, and . Supplementa, A, Theory and Systems of Legal Philosophy, I.V.R. 12 th World Congress, pp.16-22, 1985.

R. Jhering and L. Von, évolution du droit, 3 e éd, Fr. trans. O. de La Meulenaere

H. Katchadourian and «. H. , Hart's 'Primary' and 'Secondary' Legal Rules & the Institutional Character of Law, Theory and Systems of Legal Philosophy, I.V.R. 12 th World Congress, pp.204-213, 1985.

H. T. Klami, « On the So-Called Metanorms in Criminal Law, pp.143-158, 1979.

J. W. Lamb, . Chisholm, . Dodrecht, and D. Boston, « Some Definitions for the Theory of Rules Analysis and Metaphhysics. Essays in Honor of R, Philosophical Studies Series in Philosophy », vol.4, pp.273-282, 1975.

K. K. Lee and . Hart, s Primary and Secondary Rules », in Mind, A Quarterly review of Psychology and Philosophy, vol.77, pp.561-564, 1968.

L. Lindahl and D. Boston, Position and change. A Study in Law and logic, Synthese Library Stig Kanger's Theory of Rights Logic Studies in Logic and the Foundations of Mathematics, pp.889-911, 1977.

D. Lyons, The Correlativity of Rights and Duties, Noûs, pp.45-55, 1970.
DOI : 10.2307/2214291

-. Le-droit-comme-fait-institutionnel, ». , I. N. Maccormick, and O. Weinberger, Pour une théorie institutionnelle du droit. Nouvelles approches du positivisme juridique, La pensée juridique moderne, pp.51-80, 1992.

D. Makinson, « On the Formal Representation of Rights Relations. Remarks on the Work of Stig Kanger and Lars Lindahl, Journal of Philosophical Logic, vol.15, pp.403-425, 1986.

V. Mathieu and . Sistemi-logici-e-sistemi-giuridici, Impossibilità di autofondazione formale, pp.225-231, 1970.

-. Metaregole, Logica deontica e linguaggio giuridico, Padova, Cedam, coll. « Pubblicazioni della Università di Pavia Studi nelle scienze giuridiche e sociali », Nuova serie, Nuova civilta delle machine Metanorme. Rilievi su un concetto scomodo della teoria del diritto Struttura e dinamica dei sistemi giuridici Permesso forte e permesso debole: note a margine Analisi e diritto, pp.3-4, 1985.

D. Mendonca, Las claves del derecho, 2000.

R. Moore, ». Permission, and I. A. , Legal Norms and Legal Science. A Critical Study of Kelsen's Pure Theory of Law, pp.327-346, 1973.

M. Moritz, Erlaubnissätze und deontische Logik

H. Moritz, Philosophical Essays Dedicated to Gunnar Aspelin, pp.108-121, 1963.

P. Mullock, « The Permissivenes of Powers, Ratio, pp.76-81, 1974.

C. S. Nino, « Las limitaciones de la teoría de Hart sobre las normas jurídicas, Anuario de Filosofía Jurídica y Social, pp.75-93, 1985.

B. Parekh, Jeremy Bentham ? Critical Assessments, 1993.

E. Pattaro, Se la logica si applichi alle norme, pp.511-519, 1986.

E. Picavet, Approches du concret Une introduction à l'épistémologie, préf, J.-P. Séris, 1995.

. Timsit, Raisonnement juridique et interprétation, De Republica ? 3, Travaux de l'Ecole doctorale de droit public et de droit fiscal, pp.11-34, 2001.

W. V. Quine, « On What There Is From a Logical Point of View. 9 Logico-Philosophical Essays, 2 nd ed. revised, Cambridge (Mass, Ontological Relativity and Other Essays coll. « L'ordre philosophique, pp.1-19, 1969.

J. Rawls, Two Concepts of Rules, Theories of Ethics, pp.144-170, 1955.
DOI : 10.2307/2182230

R. Rorty and . Introduction, Pragmatism and Philosophy Consequences of Pragmatism (Essays: 1972-1980), pp.xiii-xlvii, 1982.

A. Ross, Towards a Realistic Jurisprudence. A Criticism of the Dualism in Law, Engl. trans. A.I, 1934.

. Norms, R. London, and . Paul, The Rise and Fall of the Doctrine of Performatives, Contemporary Philosophy in Scandinavia, pp.197-212, 1968.

U. Scarpelli, ». Modi-deontici-e-la-completezza-degli-ordinamenti-normativi, and I. Id, L'etica senza verità, pp.221-250, 1982.

F. Schauer, Playing by the Rules. A Philosophical Examination of Rule-Based Decision-Making in Law and Life, Clarendon Law Series, 1991.

L. Soler, Introduction à l'épistémologie, préf. B. d'Espagnat, 2000.

T. Spaak, The Concept of Legal Competence. An Essay in Conceptual Analysis, Engl. trans. R. Carroll, 1994.

A. Squella, « ¿Cumplen funciones meramente permisivas las normas de competencia?

N. K. Sundby, « Benthams betydning for vår tids rettstenking, Tidsskrift for Rettsvitenskap, Årg, pp.676-722, 1973.

C. F. Tapper, « Powers and Secondary Rules of Change, Oxford Essays in Jurisprudence (Second Series), pp.242-277, 1973.

G. Tusseau, J. Bentham, and . Le, Une approche de l'utilitarisme juridique, 'Harmattan, coll. « Logiques juridiques Nouvelle bibliothèque de thèses, 2000.

P. R. Visser and T. J. Bench-capon, Comparison of Four Ontologies for the Design of Legal Knowledge Systems, Artificial Intelligence and Law, pp.27-57, 1998.

-. Logica-delle-norme-e-dominî-logici, ». T. It, I. G. Castellani, and . Di-bernardo, Logica deontica e semantica Atti del Convegno tenuto a Bielefeld 17-22 marzo, Temi e disussioni Publicazioni dell'Università degli studi di Trento, pp.95-146, 1975.

C. Wellman, A Theory of Rights. Persons under Laws, Institutions and Morals, 1985.

G. Williams, The Concept of Legal Liberty, Columbia Law Review, vol.56, issue.8, pp.1129-1150, 1956.
DOI : 10.2307/1119777

G. H. Von-wright, N. Action, . Enquiry, R. London, and K. Paul, An Essay in Deontic Logic and the General Theory of Action, Amsterdam, North-Holland Publishing Company, coll. « Acta Philosophica Fennica », Fasc, On the Logic and Ontology of Norms Philosophical Logic Norms, Truth, and Logic Id., Practical Reason. Philosophical Papers, pp.89-107, 1963.

Z. Ziembi?ski, « Conditions préliminaires de l'application de la logique déontique dans les raisonnements juridiques, Etudes de logique juridique, pp.107-124, 1970.